Johns Hopkins University · Center for Research and Reform in Education

Research confirms first grade intervention has lasting impact on early literacy

Johns Hopkins University 2024–25 study finds foundational reading skills tutoring in first grade associated with durable outcomes into second grade.

1 in 8

If kids aren’t reading at grade level by the end of 1st grade, just 1 in 8 catch up the next school year.

17 in 20

When kids finish 1st grade reading at grade level, 17 in 20 will finish the next school year still reading at grade level.

First graders reading on benchmark increased dramatically with foundational reading skills tutoring

Beginning of year

End of year

6%

48%

70%

31%

Students at or above DIBELS benchmark

Students requiring intensive intervention

Students needing strategic support decreased 3%, from 24% to 21%.

Additional key findings

  • Effect size: +0.23 SD. Two-group quasi-experimental analyses result; comparable to in-person tutoring.

  • Tutored students starting far below grade level were substantially more likely than comparison peers to reach or approach proficiency by the end of the year.

No equity gaps: students across demographic groups gain more than five additional months of learning on average

Average expected growth

9 months

Ignite Reading students overall

+5.4 months

Black

+5 months

Hispanic

+5.4 months

Other

+5.6 months

White

+5.4 months

Students with IEPs

+4.6 months

English learners

+5 months

Months of learning

0

3

6

9

12

15

18

Program model

Modality

Virtual tutoring

Tutor to student ratio

1:1 instruction

Intervention delivery

Tutors with 100 hours of Science of Reading professional learning & practicum

Dosage

5 days/week × 15 minutes
85% attendance

Student sample

Massachusetts

13
Districts

1,596
Total students tutored

Demographics

43% Hispanic

34% White

11% Black

12% Other

Student groups

12%

31%

Special education students

English language learners

How the study was designed

1st grade study design

  1.  

    Students performing below grade level

  2. BOY

    Beginning of the year DIBELS test

  3.  

    Ignite Reading virtual tutoring

  4. EOY

    End of the year DIBELS test

  5.  

    One-group pretest-posttest design

    Compare to expected growth

  1.  

    Two-group quasi-experimental design

  2.  

    Match tutored students to similar non-tutored students in the same school districts

  3.  

    Compare growth of tutored students with growth of non-tutored students

2nd grade study design

  1.  

    Students who completed tutoring in 1st grade

  2.  

    No continued Ignite Reading intervention

  3. EOY

    End of the year DIBELS assessment

  4.  

    Compare outcomes: reached benchmark vs. didn't reach benchmark

See what Ignite Reading can do for your district

Source: Neitzel, A.J. (2025). Evaluation of Ignite Reading virtual literacy tutoring in Massachusetts: Year 2 quantitative findings, School Year 2024–25. Center for Research and Reform in Education, The Johns Hopkins University.